Think of a time you sent an email and never got a reply.
You wait, refresh your inbox, and eventually give up - frustrated, and maybe a little disappointed in whoever was on the other end.
That same feeling is what customers experience when they enquire about a car and don’t hear back.
For brands looking at ways of improving dealer lead follow-up, this moment matters more than most. Every unanswered call or broken promise quietly chips away at trust - and at sales.
Why Communication Gets Missed
Most Sales Executives want to do the right thing. They’re not ignoring leads - they’re juggling a busy day that never quite goes to plan.
A test drive runs over. A walk-in arrives. A finance question turns into a 20-minute call.
That promised callback “after lunch” slips down the list, and by the end of the day, it’s forgotten.
It’s not neglect - it’s noise.
With multiple systems to manage, limited visibility, and competing priorities, even the best teams lose track sometimes. From the outside, that silence looks like inconsistency. In reality, it’s a process problem.
The Tenacity Gap
Our data shows that the best-performing networks make around five attempts per lead, usually by phone.
That isn’t about pestering customers - it’s about persistence. Dealers who follow up consistently see higher appointment rates and stronger conversion because they give themselves more chances to connect.
Others stop after just one or two attempts, often by email, and never reconnect.
Those lost opportunities are what improving dealer lead follow-up is really about - closing the gap between first contact and final conversion.
What the Data Shows
.png)
The data behind customer feedback paints a clear picture.
On the left, we’re looking at customers who scored their experience 1 to 3 - meaning something went wrong. The top reasons tell a consistent story:
- 19% said the dealer didn’t do as promised
- 15% said the dealer left a message and didn’t call again
- 15% mentioned test drive or process issues
- 18% cited a poor dealer experience overall
- And 0% complained about too many calls
That last figure is telling. Customers rarely resent follow-up - they resent silence.
On the right, you see the opposite end of the scale: the 4s and 5s. These are the experiences that customers rated highly, and they revolve around three key themes:
- 40% praised the Sales Executive’s attitude
- 25% highlighted knowledge and expertise
- 22% mentioned speed of response
Together, they show that when dealers respond quickly, communicate clearly, and follow through on what they promise, customers reward that effort.
What’s striking is how avoidable the lower scores are. They’re not driven by price or availability - they’re driven by communication gaps.
The difference between a “1” and a “5” isn’t luck or product. It’s process.
It’s doing what you said you’d do, when you said you’d do it - and making sure the customer knows you care enough to follow up.
The Cost of a Missed Promise
“Do what you said you’d do, when you said you’d do it.”
It sounds simple, but it’s one of the strongest predictors of customer satisfaction.
A missed callback doesn’t just cost a sale - it breaks confidence. To the customer, it feels personal. To the brand, it’s invisible.
Across large networks, those small moments create black holes in the customer journey - the gap between what the process says should happen and what actually does.
Visibility is the Turning Point
The solution starts with visibility.
When brands can see what’s really happening - how quickly follow-up takes place, how often dealers try to reach out, and what the customer experience looks like - they can support their networks more effectively.
It’s not about micromanaging dealers. It’s about helping them improve dealer lead follow-up through clear data, accountability, and confidence in the process.
With accurate insight, brands can set fairer targets, recognise top performers, and spot where extra coaching or resources would make the biggest impact.
Improving Dealer Lead Follow-Up: Looking Ahead
Customer expectations are evolving, and communication tools are evolving too.
New channels, like WhatsApp, are helping dealers stay connected and visible - but the principle remains the same: speed, consistency, and professionalism win every time.
The brands that get this right don’t just sell more cars - they build stronger relationships between their network and their customers.
Because customers rarely complain about being contacted too often. They complain when no one gets back to them.